{
"timestamp_utc": "2026-09-06T18:29:09.007976+00:00",
"milestone": "W5 Fourth-Swarm Review Response: Connected Capability Preservation Loop & Deterministic Gate",
"lead": "swarm6-integration (Workstream A + Gate Owner)",
"bead": "klbr-agy",
"status": "completed",
"summary": "Fourth-swarm review response successfully implemented and verified: 1. Durable causes (InputFrame, DeadlineWake, MaintenanceReady, CheckDue) persisted in SQLite migration 003_work.sql. 2. Observer cursor advance and case/work row committed atomically in ONE transaction. 3. Production runner selects work via select_next_work_item based on consequence priority; no fake user messages created. 4. Startup recovery and periodic driver scan for ready pending work items. 5. Coherent identity-checked runner retirement removes active owner and resets executing state. 6. Test-local fake types (WorkCategory, WorkCandidate, SchedulableTask, CheckStatus) deleted from v2_integration_test.rs; real production APIs called. 7. Single deterministic end-to-end gate test implemented and passing across all 7 boundaries with negative fault injections. 8. Honest reclassification: G10, G11, G20, G26 downgraded with explicit labels (a) source/helper, (b) deterministic execution, (c) model authorship: NOT RUN, (d) observed benefit: NOT RUN.",
"scenarios": {
"G01": {
"name": "Autonomous wake without user input",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::review_deadline_wake_makes_another_model_request_without_new_input"
},
"G02": {
"name": "Causal transcript groups survive interleaving",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::review_interleaved_input_preserves_causal_tool_group_on_reconstruction"
},
"G03": {
"name": "Tool-result commit required before inference",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::review_failed_tool_result_commit_prevents_next_model_step"
},
"G04": {
"name": "Recovery when maintenance breaks",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g04_recovery_remains_available_when_maintenance_blocks"
},
"G05": {
"name": "Origin symmetry human vs agent",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g05_origin_symmetry_human_and_agent_identical_treatment"
},
"G06": {
"name": "Reliability repair outranks feature",
"status": "passed",
"honesty_label": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g06_self_diagnosed_reliability_repair_outranks_feature (calls production klbr_runtime::work::select_next_work_item; test-local WorkCandidate/score deleted)"
},
"G07": {
"name": "Checkup finds silent degradation",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "test_checks.py::test_g07_guidance_delivery_check"
},
"G08": {
"name": "Aging prevents maintenance starvation",
"status": "passed",
"honesty_label": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g08_aging_and_fairness_prevents_maintenance_starvation (calls production klbr_runtime::work::project_priority_score and select_next_work_item; test-local SchedulableTask deleted)"
},
"G09": {
"name": "Observer retries retain evidence",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "test_checks.py::test_g09_observation_grouping_and_deduplication"
},
"G10": {
"name": "Agent originates API repair",
"status": "downgraded_deterministic_only",
"honesty_label": "(a) source/helper implementation + (b) deterministic execution via scripted candidate plumbing in single_deterministic_e2e_gate; (c) real model authorship: NOT RUN; (d) later observed benefit: NOT RUN (behavioral gate: NOT RUN)",
"evidence": "CandidateWorkspace in Python / Release in Rust verified deterministically; real model autonomous authorship: NOT RUN"
},
"G11": {
"name": "Natural correction transfers across session restart",
"status": "downgraded_deterministic_only",
"honesty_label": "(a) source/helper implementation + (b) deterministic execution (guidance delivery verified; post-restart candidate adoption verified in single_deterministic_e2e_gate); (c) real model authorship: NOT RUN; (d) later observed benefit: NOT RUN (behavioral gate: NOT RUN)",
"evidence": "test_single_deterministic_e2e_gate_crosses_all_boundaries step 6; GuidanceStore snapshot persistence"
},
"G12": {
"name": "Context omission is explicit",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "context_receipt.rs"
},
"G13": {
"name": "Unknown and stale checks do not certify health",
"status": "passed",
"honesty_label": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g13_stale_and_unknown_checks_do_not_certify_health (calls production klbr_core::capability_check::CheckResult and DerivedStatus; test-local CheckStatus deleted)"
},
"G14": {
"name": "Invalid await does not duplicate mutation",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "test_maintenance.py::test_sync_awaited_mutation_does_not_repeat"
},
"G15": {
"name": "Learner rejects audit diagnosis",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "test_maintenance.py::test_targeted_test_claim_contradiction_rejects_global_ban"
},
"G16": {
"name": "Healthy checkups end without change",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g16_healthy_checkups_end_without_unnecessary_change"
},
"G17": {
"name": "Successful friction produces improvement",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "capability_check.rs"
},
"G18": {
"name": "Host activation preserves pinning and rejects tampered",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "v2_integration_test.rs::g18_host_activation_preserves_pinning_and_rejects_tampered"
},
"G19": {
"name": "Regression triggers reopening and rollback",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "session.rs CAS validation"
},
"G20": {
"name": "Benefit measured against opportunities",
"status": "downgraded_not_run",
"honesty_label": "(a) source/helper implementation; (c) real model authorship: NOT RUN; (d) later observed benefit: NOT RUN (behavioral gate: NOT RUN)",
"evidence": "ContextReceipt opportunity metrics definition exists; real model longitudinal benefit: NOT RUN"
},
"G21": {
"name": "Restore capability first without losing structural issue",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "work.rs dependency tracking"
},
"G22": {
"name": "Maintainability and access checkups",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "test_checks.py::test_g22_resource_access_check"
},
"G23": {
"name": "Origin neutrality prevents spoofing",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "ingress.rs SourceRef canonical dedupe"
},
"G24": {
"name": "Maintenance remains off token hot path",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "runtime_turn supervisor"
},
"G25": {
"name": "Maintenance diagnostics are not accidental speech",
"status": "passed",
"evidence": "streaming-v2.test.ts::lifecycle diagnostics update healthStore..."
},
"G26": {
"name": "Evaluation checks useful work",
"status": "downgraded_not_run",
"honesty_label": "(a) source/helper implementation; (c) real model authorship: NOT RUN; (d) later observed benefit: NOT RUN (behavioral gate: NOT RUN)",
"evidence": "Evaluation harness exists; real model trial: NOT RUN"
}
},
"client_ui": {
"health_statuses": [
"healthy",
"degraded",
"unavailable",
"unknown",
"stale"
],
"provenance_origins": [
"human",
"agent",
"checker",
"system"
],
"stores": [
"healthStore",
"workItemsStore",
"candidateStore"
],
"lane_separation_enforced": true
},
"single_deterministic_e2e_gate": {
"test": "single_deterministic_e2e_gate::test_single_deterministic_e2e_gate_crosses_all_boundaries",
"command": "cargo test -p klbr-daemon --test v2_integration_test -- test_single_deterministic_e2e_gate_crosses_all_boundaries",
"status": "passed",
"boundaries_verified": {
"1_genuine_observation": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; fault produces observation via production observe_turn_failure without user refinement request; negative injection verified (failed commit preserves cursor & work state)",
"2_persisted_maintenance_item": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; atomic commit of cursor advance, observer case, and work item through production observe_turn_failure/commit_observation_case_with_cursor",
"3_restart_and_scheduler_selection": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; store reopened, startup scan recovers item, select_next_work_item selects it",
"4_provider_request_captured": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; production MaintenanceAttemptContext::assemble_messages used; turn executed under Purpose::Maintenance; captured request asserted for Fresh-context maintenance attempt marker, exact ref id=\"event:1\", and purpose=\"repair\"",
"5_deterministic_fake_actor": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; candidate edit/test flow verified (scripted plumbing evidence, not autonomous diagnosis)",
"6_host_check_and_activation": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; tampered hook rejection verified; release activated and post-restart session adopts candidate without special lesson",
"7_client_diagnostics_and_lane_purity": "(b) deterministic end-to-end execution; projected through real daemon query_events_after and project_event; canonical lifecycle events produce Lane::Lifecycle with {kind, data} and 0 events to Lane::Speech"
},
"behavioral_gate": "NOT RUN (real model unavailable in automated headless test environment)"
},
"residual_not_wired_helpers": [
{
"component": "klbr_core::context_receipt::GuidanceAssemblyEngine",
"current_status": "No production caller in daemon request assembler",
"detail": "Context receipt at the real provider-request assembler is not wired; maintenance/turn assembler does not record a version-bound receipt yet",
"next_owner": "Evidence / Context Lead (Task A)"
},
{
"component": "klbr_core::capability_check::ObservationProcessor::process_new_events",
"current_status": "No production caller",
"detail": "The daemon observes faults directly via observe_turn_failure; the batch grouping processor itself is still unused in production daemon paths",
"next_owner": "Observer / Background Worker Lead"
},
{
"component": "check_guidance_delivery / check_guidance_delivery_request",
"current_status": "No scheduled production checker exists",
"detail": "There is no periodic capability checker loop running in the daemon; checks are currently unit/integration tested directly",
"next_owner": "Capability Checker / Maintenance Lead"
}
]
}